| Acknowledgements |
|
xi | |
| List of abbreviations |
|
xii | |
| Introduction |
|
xiii | |
| 1 Judging the end(ing) of life: conflict and confusion |
|
1 | |
|
1 Conceptual rights and conceptual wrongs: defining 'euthanasia' |
|
|
3 | |
|
1.1 Humpty Dumpty at the end of life |
|
|
4 | |
|
1.2 Towards a working definition of 'euthanasia' |
|
|
8 | |
|
2 Moral rights and moral wrongs |
|
|
9 | |
|
2.1 The intrinsic value of life |
|
|
10 | |
|
2.2 Choosing the value of life |
|
|
13 | |
|
2.3 The instrumental value of life |
|
|
15 | |
|
2.4 Executioners on slippery slopes |
|
|
17 | |
|
3 Assessing the rights and wrongs of ending life |
|
|
21 | |
|
3.1 The intrinsic value of life |
|
|
21 | |
|
3.2 Choosing the value of life |
|
|
24 | |
|
3.3 The instrumental value of life |
|
|
26 | |
|
3.4 Executioners on slippery slopes |
|
|
27 | |
|
4 Conclusion: conflict and confusion at the end of life |
|
|
30 | |
| 2 Not Pretty: 'mercy killing' in legal fact and legal fiction |
|
32 | |
|
1 The mercy killer as murderer |
|
|
34 | |
|
2 The mercy killer at 'breaking point' |
|
|
37 | |
|
2.1 Accommodating the mercy killer |
|
|
37 | |
|
2.2 Stretching a (breaking) point |
|
|
39 | |
|
2.3 Diminishing the mercy killer |
|
|
40 | |
|
3 The 'unique' mercy killer |
|
|
42 | |
|
3.1 Before the breaking point |
|
|
43 | |
|
3.2 After the breaking point |
|
|
44 | |
|
3.3 The 'unique 'mercy killer |
|
|
45 | |
|
4 Locating the mercy killer |
|
|
46 | |
|
4.1 When is a killing not a mercy killing? |
|
|
47 | |
|
4.2 When is a killing a mercy killing? |
|
|
48 | |
|
4.3 Pretty, not Pretty and the sentencing lottery |
|
|
49 | |
|
5 The mercy killer: presumed innocent? |
|
|
50 | |
|
6 Conclusion: collusion, compromise and confusion |
|
|
52 | |
| 3 Assisted suicide in 'the shadowy area of mercy killing' |
|
55 | |
|
1 What is assisted suicide? |
|
|
57 | |
|
1.1 Guilty for aiding the innocent |
|
|
58 | |
|
|
|
58 | |
|
1.3 Assisting, assisting an attempt, and attempting to assist in an attempt |
|
|
59 | |
|
1.4 Pills, pillows and pistols |
|
|
60 | |
|
2 Looking for borders in 'shadowy areas' |
|
|
62 | |
|
2.1 Stretching the borders of assisted suicide |
|
|
62 | |
|
2.2 Assisted suicide beyond the borders: the curious case of 'death tourism' |
|
|
63 | |
|
2.3 The classic case of providing the pills |
|
|
66 | |
|
|
|
68 | |
|
2.4.1 Passive complicity in suicide |
|
|
70 | |
|
2.4.2 Innocent doctors and guilty relatives |
|
|
72 | |
|
2.4.3 Left to die or abandoned to die |
|
|
73 | |
|
3 The 'unique' mercy killer revisited |
|
|
77 | |
|
4 A right to assisted suicide |
|
|
79 | |
|
4.1 Dianne Pretty's failure: the right to die denied |
|
|
79 | |
|
4.2 Why Dianne Pretty failed |
|
|
81 | |
|
5 Conclusion: complicity, compromise and confusion |
|
|
82 | |
| 4 Get out of jail free? Double effect and doctors in the dock |
|
84 | |
|
1 Double effect in English law |
|
|
87 | |
|
2 Clarifying the clinical confusion |
|
|
88 | |
|
2.1 Clarifying the clinical concepts |
|
|
89 | |
|
2.2 When double effect matters |
|
|
89 | |
|
2.3 Double effect or covert euthanasia |
|
|
91 | |
|
|
|
92 | |
|
3.1 The guilty...father and the innocent doctor |
|
|
92 | |
|
3.2 Double effect or covert euthanasia (revisited) |
|
|
94 | |
|
3.3 Double effect in the dock |
|
|
96 | |
|
|
|
99 | |
|
|
|
100 | |
|
4.1 The guilty layperson and the innocent doctor (revisited) |
|
|
100 | |
|
|
|
101 | |
|
|
|
102 | |
|
|
|
102 | |
|
5.1 Overstretching the judicial reach |
|
|
102 | |
|
5.2 The guilty layperson and the innocent doctor (re-revisited) |
|
|
104 | |
|
|
|
105 | |
|
6 Beyond the boundaries of double effect |
|
|
106 | |
|
|
|
107 | |
|
6.2 Engaging the jury's sympathy |
|
|
109 | |
|
6.3 Directing the jury and directing the result |
|
|
110 | |
|
6.4 Get out of jail free (revisited) |
|
|
112 | |
|
7 Conclusion: compromise or confusion? |
|
|
112 | |
| 5 Beyond Bland: hedging bets on the value of life? |
|
115 | |
|
1 Quinlan's challenge: letting die and letting morality in |
|
|
117 | |
|
|
|
117 | |
|
1.2 Letting die as a moral matter |
|
|
119 | |
|
1.3 Duties, doctors and intruders |
|
|
120 | |
|
2 Beyond Bland: the problem of fatal omissions |
|
|
123 | |
|
2.1 Bland's challenge: letting the incompetent patient die |
|
|
123 | |
|
2.2 Karapetian's challenge: duties, doctors and intruders (revisited) |
|
|
126 | |
|
2.3 Diverting doctors from the dock |
|
|
128 | |
|
2.4 Beyond Bland: letting die as a moral matter (revisited) |
|
|
130 | |
|
3 Doctrinal difficulties: what is the value of life? |
|
|
131 | |
|
3.1 The intrinsic value of life |
|
|
131 | |
|
3.2 From intrinsic value to instrumental value |
|
|
133 | |
|
3.3 From intrinsic value to self-determined value |
|
|
136 | |
|
4 Conclusion: hedging bets on the value of life |
|
|
139 | |
| 6 Euthanasia and the middle ground: from conflict to compromise |
|
141 | |
|
1 From conflict to creativity and consensus |
|
|
143 | |
|
1.1 Condoning conflict and confusion |
|
|
144 | |
|
1.2 Creativity at the end of life |
|
|
145 | |
|
1.3 Consensus and convergence at the end of life |
|
|
146 | |
|
2 The case for compromise |
|
|
149 | |
|
2.1 The conditions of compromise |
|
|
149 | |
|
|
|
151 | |
|
3 The contours of compromise |
|
|
155 | |
|
3.1 Compromise by committee |
|
|
155 | |
|
3.2 Moral discomfort, justification and excuse |
|
|
158 | |
|
3.3 Clarifying the compromise on fatal omissions |
|
|
160 | |
|
3.4 Clarifying the double effect |
|
|
162 | |
|
3.5 Clarifying the 'shadowy area' of mercy killing |
|
|
165 | |
|
4 Conclusion: from conflict to compromise |
|
|
172 | |
| Bibliography |
|
175 | |
| Index |
|
199 | |