Muutke küpsiste eelistusi

E-raamat: Comparative Succession Law: Volume I: Testamentary Formalities, v. I, Testamentary Formalities [Oxford Scholarship Online e-raamatud]

Edited by (Professor of Private Law, University of Stellenbosch), Edited by (Professor of Scots Law, University of Edinburgh), Edited by (Director of the Max Planck Institute for Foreign Private and Private International Law, Hamburg)
  • Formaat: 524 pages
  • Ilmumisaeg: 06-Oct-2011
  • Kirjastus: Oxford University Press
  • ISBN-13: 9780199696802
  • Oxford Scholarship Online e-raamatud
  • Raamatu hind pole hetkel teada
  • Formaat: 524 pages
  • Ilmumisaeg: 06-Oct-2011
  • Kirjastus: Oxford University Press
  • ISBN-13: 9780199696802
Launching a major new research project examining the principles of succession law in comparative perspective, this book discusses the formalities which the law imposes in order for a person to make a testamentary disposal of property. Among the questions considered are the following. How are wills made? What precisely are the rules - as to the signature of the testator, the use of witnesses, the need for a notary public or lawyer, and so on? Is there is a choice of will-type and, if so, which type is used most often and what are the advantages and disadvantages of each? How common is will-making or do most people die intestate? What happens if formalities are not observed? How can requirements of form be explained and justified? How did the law develop historically, what is the state of the law today, and what are the prospects for the future?

The focus is on Europe, and on countries which have been influenced by the European experience. Thus in addition to giving a detailed treatment of the law in Austria, Belgium, England and Wales, France, Germany, Hungary, Italy, the Netherlands, Poland, and Spain, the book explores legal developments in Australia, New Zealand, the United States of America, and in some of the countries of Latin America with a particular emphasis on Brazil. It also includes chapters on two of the mixed jurisdictions - Scotland and South Africa - and on Islamic Law. The book opens with chapters on Roman law and on the early modern law in Europe, thus setting the historical scene as well as anticipating and complementing the accounts of national history which appear in subsequent chapters; and it concludes with an assessment of the overall development of the law in the countries surveyed, and with some wider reflections on the nature and purpose of testamentary formalities.
Preface x
List of Contributors
xii
List of Abbreviations
xiii
1 Testamentary Formalities in Roman Law
1(26)
Thomas Rufnser
I Introduction
2(1)
II Archaic and pre-classical law
3(2)
III Classical law
5(13)
IV Post-classical law
18(7)
V Conclusion
25(2)
2 Testamentary Formalities in Early Modern Europe
27(24)
Nils Jansen
I Introduction
27(6)
II Wills and codicils
33(2)
III The forms of will
35(11)
IV Internal formalities
46(3)
V Conclusion
49(2)
3 Testamentary Formalities in France and Belgium
51(20)
Walter Pintens
I Introduction
52(1)
II Historical development
53(2)
III The modern law
55(2)
IV Holograph wills
57(5)
V Public wills
62(2)
VI Secret wills
64(1)
VII International wills
65(3)
VIII Registration
68(1)
IX Procedure after death
69(1)
X Conclusion
70(1)
4 Testamentary Formalities in Spain
71(25)
Sergio Camara Lapuente
I Introduction
72(1)
II Historical background
73(4)
III The modern law
77(2)
IV Open wills
79(3)
V Closed wills
82(1)
VI Holograph wills
83(2)
VII Special wills
85(1)
VIII Shared features
86(4)
IX Internal formalities
90(1)
X A shift from formalism
91(1)
XI Concluding remarks
92(1)
XII Appendix: the laws of the Autonomous Communities
93(3)
5 Testamentary Formalities in Latin America with particular reference to Brazil
96(24)
Jan Peter Schmidt
I The Latin American background
97(1)
II Wills and will-making
98(3)
III Public wills
101(3)
IV Sealed wills
104(1)
V Private wills
105(3)
VI The fate of the holograph will
108(2)
VII Extraordinary wills
110(4)
VIII Further aspects
114(3)
IX Court practice and the flight from formalism
117(2)
X Concluding remarks
119(1)
6 Testamentary Formalities in Italy
120(22)
Alexandra Braun
I Historical introduction
121(1)
II Wills and will-substitutes
122(4)
III Holograph wills
126(4)
IV Notarial wills
130(4)
V Special wills
134(2)
VI International wills
136(1)
VII Evaluation
137(1)
VIII Defects of form
138(2)
IX Conclusion
140(2)
7 Testamentary Formalities in the Netherlands
142(33)
Wilbert D Kolkman
I Historical overview
143(4)
II Types of will
147(14)
III Evidence
161(3)
IV Special features of testamentary formalities
164(6)
V Adherence to formalities
170(3)
VI Concluding remarks
173(2)
8 Testamentary Formalities in Germany
175(46)
Reinhard Zimmermann
I Introduction
176(1)
II Private wills in nineteenth-century Germany
177(3)
III Holograph wills: principle and exceptions
180(2)
IV The battle over holograph wills: travaux preparatoires of the BGB
182(5)
V The holograph will and the courts (1900--35)
187(6)
VI Another battle over holograph wills
193(4)
VII Holograph wills today
197(8)
VIII Public wills
205(7)
IX Extraordinary wills
212(6)
X The German experience: a general assessment
218(3)
9 Testamentary Formalities in Austria
221(33)
Christiane C Wendehorst
I Relevant instruments and their practical significance
223(5)
II Historical development
228(9)
III Modern doctrine and court practice
237(14)
IV Current debates and plans for reform
251(2)
V Summary
253(1)
10 Testamentary Formalities in Hungary
254(16)
Lajos Vekas
I Introduction
255(2)
II Common requirements for wills
257(1)
III Private wills
258(7)
IV Public wills
265(1)
V Oral wills for emergency situations
265(2)
VI Legal consequences of formal mistakes
267(1)
VII Summary: relaxation of testamentary formalities
268(2)
11 Testamentary Formalities in Poland
270(12)
Fryderyk Zoll
I Historical development
270(2)
II The modern law
272(2)
III Holograph wills
274(3)
IV Notarial wills
277(1)
V Allograph wills
278(1)
VI Emergency wills
279(2)
VII Recodification
281(1)
12 Testamentary Formalities in Islamic Law and their Reception in the Modern Laws of Islamic Countries
282(23)
Nadjma Yassari
I Introduction
282(2)
II Classical Islamic law
284(11)
III Modern laws
295(8)
IV Conclusion
303(2)
13 Testamentary Formalities in England and Wales
305(24)
Roger Kerridge
I Introduction
306(1)
II Formal wills: a history
307(5)
III The Wills Act 1837
312(4)
IV Incorporation by reference
316(1)
V Wills statistics
316(1)
VI Administration of estates
317(1)
VII Preparation and registration of wills
318(3)
VIII Forgery
321(1)
IX Nuncupative wills
322(3)
X Holograph wills
325(1)
XI Alterations
325(1)
XII Reform
326(3)
14 Testamentary Formalities in Australia and New Zealand
329(28)
Nicola Peart
I Introduction
330(3)
II Historical overview
333(3)
III Wills of indigenous peoples
336(1)
IV Special wills
337(2)
V The current law
339(10)
VI Power to dispense with testamentary formalities
349(6)
VII Conclusion
355(2)
15 Testamentary Formalities in the United States of America
357(24)
Ronald J Scalise Jr
I Introduction
358(2)
II Testamentary formalities
360(16)
III Incorporation by reference and alterations
376(3)
IV Conclusion
379(2)
16 Testamentary Formalities in South Africa
381(23)
Marius J de Waal
I Introduction
382(2)
II Historical background
384(1)
III The scope of the Wills Act
385(2)
IV The essential formalities
387(8)
V Procedure after death
395(1)
VI Condonation
395(6)
VII Amendment
401(1)
VIII Concluding remarks
402(2)
17 Testamentary Formalities in Scotland
404(28)
Kenneth G C Reid
I Conveyances and testaments
405(7)
II Seals, signatures, and witnesses
412(7)
III The modern law
419(10)
IV Form and formalism
429(3)
18 Testamentary Formalities in Historical and Comparative Perspective
432(41)
Kenneth G C Reid
Marius J de Waal
Reinhard Zimmermann
I Wills and will-making
433(4)
II Holograph wills
437(7)
III Witnessed wills
444(4)
IV Public wills
448(3)
V Special wills
451(4)
VI Shared features
455(7)
VII The flight from formalities
462(6)
VIII Some conclusions
468(5)
Index 473
A qualified solicitor, Kenneth Reid has taught at the University of Edinburgh since 1980. He was appointed to the Chair of Property Law in 1994 and to the Chair of Scots Law in 2008. From 1995 to 2005 he served as a Scottish Law Commissioner, where he was responsible for a major programme of reform of land law, which was implemented by legislation.

Marius de Waal is Professor of Private Law at the University of Stellenbosch. His main fields of interest are the law of succession and the law of trusts, on which he has written a number of textbooks, including co-authoring the the fifth edition of Honoré's South African Law of Trusts (Juta 2002, with Edwin Cameron, Basil Wunsh and Peter Solomon).

Reinhard Zimmermann is a Director of the Max Planck Institute for Comparative and International Private Law in Hamburg and is Chairman of the Social Sciences, Arts, and Humanities Division of the Max Planck Society. He is the author of numerous books on comparative law and legal history, including The Law of Obligations (OUP, 1996) and The New German Law of Obligations (OUP, 2005).