Muutke küpsiste eelistusi

Many Reasons to Intervene: French and British Approaches to Humanitarian Action [Pehme köide]

Edited by , Edited by
  • Formaat: Paperback / softback, 176 pages, kõrgus x laius: 216x138 mm
  • Ilmumisaeg: 01-Jul-2011
  • Kirjastus: C Hurst & Co Publishers Ltd
  • ISBN-10: 1849041423
  • ISBN-13: 9781849041423
  • Formaat: Paperback / softback, 176 pages, kõrgus x laius: 216x138 mm
  • Ilmumisaeg: 01-Jul-2011
  • Kirjastus: C Hurst & Co Publishers Ltd
  • ISBN-10: 1849041423
  • ISBN-13: 9781849041423
In the humanitarian field those we rather mockingly call 'French doctors' seem always to be in the vanguard, the first to arrive in any critical situation. If they hold such a position in modern humanitarian intervention it is because these French doctors - first and foremost Medecins Sans Frontieres and its 'little sister' Medecins du Monde - have created a style of humanitarian action that combines intervention in crises with critical assessment of and commentary on the human tragedies -- wars, famines, earthquakes -- in which they find themselves involved. The humanitarian practices we are familiar with today were devised, through trial and errors, by agencies in the United States, Great Britain and Switzerland. France was the last to join the group of so-called 'founder democracies' in the humanitarian field. A closer examination of the history of humanitarianism reveals that it was by drawing on already existing forms of action that MSF, MDM and many others gradually developed its particular brand of intervention, which combines relief practices learnt from the Red Cross with efforts to mobilise public opinion using strategies invented by Amnesty International. The contributors to this volume assess the competing French and 'Anglo-Saxon' models of intervention in the hope of learning from both and formulating approaches to humanitarianism for the twenty-first century. CONTRIBUTORS: Philippe Ryfman, Hugo Slim, Egbert Sondorp, Francois Grunewald, Hugh Goyder, Sami Makki, James Darcy, Christophe Courtin, Adeel Jafferi.

Arvustused

'The idea of contrasting French and British approaches to humanitarian action and simultaneously questioning the adequacy of a simple dichotomy between the two is worthwhile. Key issues - about the nature of humanitarianism, the relationships between humanitarianism and development, the questions of independence and neutrality - are discussed in novel ways and the differing assumptions of the authors force readers to think about their own positions.' * Professor Michael Newman, author, Humanitarian Intervention: Confronting the Contradictions *

About the Editors vii
About the Contributors ix
Preface xiii
Rony Brauman
1 The Bishop's Diagonal Versus the Axis of Evil: Strategies on the Geopolitical Chessboard
1(6)
Karl Blanchet
Boris Martin
PART 1 Maturity Crisis
7(42)
2 Crises of Maturity and Transformation in French NGOs
9(18)
Philippe Ryfman
3 Establishment Radicals: An Historical Overview of British NGOs
27(14)
Hugo Slim
4 French or Anglo-Saxon: A Different Ethical Perspective?
41(8)
Egbert Sondorp
PART 2 Should Humanitarian Action be Evaluated?
49(22)
5 Evaluation for Change: How Can We Improve the Impact of Humanitarian Action?
51(10)
Francois Grunewald
6 Learning, Monitoring and Evaluation
61(10)
Hugh Goyder
PART 3 NGOs on the New Geopolitical Chessboard
71(28)
7 International NGOs Under Fire: Caught Between the Global Fight Against Terrorism and Neo-Liberal Approaches to Security Governance
73(14)
Sami Makki
8 Patronage or Influence? International Politics and the Changing Role of Non-Governmental Humanitarian Organisations
87(12)
James Darcy
PART 4 Humanitarianism And Religion
99(22)
9 Christian NGOs on the International Scene: What are their Motives?
101(10)
Christophe Courtin
10 Is There an Islamic Humanitarianism?
111(10)
Adeel Jafferi
Epilogue 121(4)
David Rieff
Notes 125(8)
Useful Websites 133(2)
Index 135
Karl Blanchet is a research at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine. Boris Martin is Editor of the French journal Humanitaire, published by Medecins du Monde- France. He is also an independent publisher and author.