Muutke küpsiste eelistusi

My Psalm Has Turned into Weeping: Job's Dialogue with the Psalms [Kõva köide]

Drawing inspiration from the widely recognized parody of Ps 8:5 in Job 7:17–18, this study inquires whether other allusions to the Psalms might likewise contribute to the dialogue between Job, his friends, and God. An intertextual method that incorporates both “diachronic” and “synchronic” concerns is applied to the sections of Job and the Psalms in which the intertextual connections are the most pronounced, the Job dialogue and six psalms that fall into three broad categories: praise (8, 107), supplication (39, 139), and instruction (1, 73). In each case, Job’s dependence on the Psalms is determined to be the more likely explanation of the parallel, and, in most, allusions to the same psalm appear in the speeches of both Job and the friends. The contrasting uses to which they put these psalms reflect conflicting interpretive approaches and uncover latent tensions within them by capitalizing on their ambiguities. They also provide historical insight into the Psalms’ authority and developing views of retribution. The dialogue created between Job and these psalms indicates the concern the book has with the proper response to suffering and the role the interpretation of authoritative texts may play in that reaction.



Acknowledgements v
Abbreviations xi
1 Hearing History: Connections between Job and the Psalms in the History of Interpretation
1(16)
1.1 Introduction
1(2)
1.2 Early Critical Interpretation
3(7)
1.3 Form Criticism
10(3)
1.4 Intertextuality
13(3)
1.4.1 Job and the Hebrew Bible
14(1)
1.4.2 Job and the Psalms
15(1)
1.5 Conclusion
16(1)
2 Between Times, Between Texts: Intertextualities in Dialogue
17(46)
2.1 Introduction
17(4)
2.2 The False Dichotomy
21(3)
2.3 Between Diachronic and Synchronic
24(3)
2.4 Intertextuality and the Hebrew Bible
27(2)
2.5 Intertextualities in Dialogue: Prolegomena
29(8)
2.5.1 Terminology
30(3)
2.5.2 The Text
33(1)
2.5.3 The Intertext
34(3)
2.6 Intertextualities in Dialogue: Eight Steps
37(22)
2.6.1 Identification
37(12)
2.6.2 Date
49(3)
2.6.3 Coherence
52(2)
2.6.4 Use
54(1)
2.6.5 Recurrence
55(1)
2.6.6 Holistic Interpretation
55(3)
2.6.7 Reciprocation
58(1)
2.6.8 Historical Implications
58(1)
2.7 Conclusion
59(4)
PART I PRAISE
3 Hubris and Humility: Psalm 8 in Job
63(17)
3.1 Identification
63(4)
3.2 Date
67(2)
3.3 Coherence
69(1)
3.4 Use
69(2)
3.5 Recurrence
71(4)
3.5.1 Eliphaz: 15:14-16
71(2)
3.5.2 Job: 19:9
73(1)
3.5.3 Bildad: 25:5-6
74(1)
3.6 Holistic Interpretation
75(1)
3.7 Reciprocation
76(1)
3.8 Historical Implications
77(1)
3.9 Conclusion
78(2)
4 Doxology in Disputation: Psalm 107 in Job
80(21)
4.1 Identification
80(2)
4.2 Date
82(1)
4.3 Coherence
83(3)
4.4 Use
86(1)
4.5 Recurrence
87(6)
4.5.1 Eliphaz: Ch. 5
87(2)
4.5.2 Job: 12:13-13:2
89(2)
4.5.3 Eliphaz: 15:24
91(1)
4.5.4 Job: 21:11
92(1)
4.5.5 Eliphaz: 22:19
93(1)
4.6 Holistic Interpretation
93(1)
4.7 Reciprocation
94(1)
4.8 Historical Implications
95(1)
4.9 Conclusion
96(5)
4.9.1 Psalms of Praise in Job
97(4)
PART II SUPPLICATION
5 Ominous Omniscience?: Psalm 139 in Job
101(21)
5.1 Identification
102(2)
5.2 Date
104(1)
5.3 Coherence
105(2)
5.4 Use
107(1)
5.5 Recurrence
108(9)
5.5.1 Job: Ch. 10
108(4)
5.5.2 Zophar: 11:7-9
112(3)
5.5.3 Job: 23:8-10
115(2)
5.6 Holistic Interpretation
117(2)
5.7 Reciprocation
119(2)
5.8 Historical Implications
121(1)
5.9 Conclusion
121(1)
6 Harassed Hope: Psalm 39 in Job
122(23)
6.1 Identification
123(2)
6.2 Date
125(1)
6.3 Coherence
126(4)
6.4 Use
130(1)
6.5 Recurrence
130(6)
6.5.1 Job: 6:8-11
130(2)
6.5.2 Job: Ch. 7
132(3)
6.5.3 Job: 13:28-14:6
135(1)
6.6 Holistic Interpretation
136(3)
6.7 Reciprocation
139(1)
6.8 Historical Implications
140(1)
6.9 Conclusion
140(5)
6.9.1 Psalms of Supplication in Job
141(4)
PART III INSTRUCTION
7 From Didactic to Dialogic: Psalm 1 in job
145(16)
7.1 Identification
145(3)
7.2 Date
148(1)
7.3 Coherence
149(1)
7.4 Use
149(2)
7.5 Recurrence
151(6)
7.5.1 Eliphaz: 5:13-14
151(1)
7.5.2 Job: 10:3
152(1)
7.5.3 Job: 13:25
153(2)
7.5.4 Eliphaz: 22:18
155(1)
7.5.5 Job: 23:10-11
155(2)
7.6 Holistic Interpretation
157(1)
7.7 Reciprocation
158(1)
7.8 Historical Implications
159(1)
7.9 Conclusion
160(1)
8 Re-interpreting Retribution: Psalm 73 in Job
161(19)
8.1 Identification
162(2)
8.2 Date
164(1)
8.3 Coherence
164(1)
8.4 Use
165(1)
8.5 Recurrence
166(8)
8.5.1 Job: 7:18
166(1)
8.5.2 Job: 9:29-31
167(1)
8.5.3 The Friends: 15:27; 18:3, 11, 14; 20:8
168(2)
8.5.4 Job: 19:25-27
170(1)
8.5.5 Job: 21:13-14
171(2)
8.5.6 Job: 23:11
173(1)
8.6 Holistic Interpretation
174(1)
8.7 Reciprocation
175(2)
8.8 Historical Implications
177(1)
8.9 Conclusion
178(2)
8.9.1 Psalms of Instruction in job
179(1)
9 Conclusion
180(11)
9.1 The Psalms in the Dialogue
180(3)
9.2 The Interpretive Conflict
183(4)
9.2.1 Job: Piety through Parody
183(2)
9.2.2 The Friends: Pious Proof-texting
185(2)
9.3 The Interpretation of the Psalms in Job
187(1)
9.4 Historical Implications
188(1)
9.5 Broader Relevance and Further Research
188(3)
Bibliography 191(22)
Index of Ancient Sources 213(9)
Index of Subjects 222(4)
Index of Authors 226
Will Kynes, University of Oxford, UK.