This collection explores and illustrates issues arising from political approaches to human rights in contrast to the more traditional moral approaches. Moral approaches conceptualize and justify human rights in terms of priority rights which are both universal and moral. In contrast, political approaches focus on those human rights practices involved in the development and operation of human rights institutions, laws and political process, all in relative independence from their alleged moral foundations. The book contributes to the understanding and analysis of political approaches, including consideration of their diversity, and discussion of their strengths and weaknesses. The choice of contributors presents a balance between those theorists who favour some version of the political approach and those who are dubious about the perceived advantages. The chapters are grouped together in parts which constitute the distinctive issues addressed in the book.
At a time when there is considerable uncertainty concerning their conceptual clarity, operation, feasibility, and their normative justifications, this volume will be of interest to those involved with the theory and practice of human rights, within law schools, and in politics and philosophy departments. It will also provide a useful resource for human rights practitioners and policy makers.
Arvustused
This is an outstanding collection of papers that address deeply contested questions about the nature and foundations of human rights, and in particular, consider to what extent an institutional, contextual, and functional approach can bypass philosophical enquiries aimed at establishing moral truths. All readers, whether they are new to these debates or already well acquainted with them, will be richly rewarded.
Jeffrey Goldsworthy, Monash University
Contents
List of Contributors
Introduction Tom Campbell and Kylie Bourne
Part One: Identifying Political Approaches
1. Tom Campbell, Human Rights Morality and Human Rights Practice: An
Interactive Approach
2 Caroline West, Human Rights for Non-Believers
3 Duncan Ivison, Traces of Recognition: Rights and Political Realism
4 Jovana Davidovic, A Practical Account of the Concept of Human Rights
5 Suzy Killmister, Deriving Human Rights from Human Dignity: A Novel
Political Approach
Part Two: Critiquing Political Approaches
6 John Tasioulas, Exiting the Hall of Mirrors: Morality and Law in Human
Rights
7 Denise Meyerson, The Mismatch between Theory and Practice in Recent
Theorizing about Human Rights
8 Jim Allan, Human Rights, Doubts and Democracy
Part Three: Accommodating Economic Rights
9 Octavio Luiz Motta Ferraz, Two Conceptions of Social and Economic Rights:
Basic Needs versus Equality
10 David Kinley, The Politics of Human Rights and Finance
11 Laura Valentini, Human Rights, the Political View and Transnational
Corporations: An Exploration
Part Four: Beyond the Nation State?
12 Sonu Bedi, The Absence of Horizontal Effect in Human Rights Law: Domestic
Violence and the Intimate Sphere
13 Seumas Miller, The "Human" Right to Self-Defence: Natural, Institutional
or Political Right?
14 Kylie Bourne, Beitzs Two Level Model of Human Rights and Statelessness
Conclusion
Rhiannon Neilsen and Tom Campbell, An Overview of Political Approaches to
Human Rights
Index
Tom Campbell is a Research Associate at Charles Sturt University, Australia, formerly Professorial Fellow in the Centre for Applied Philosophy and Public Ethics (CAPPE), previously Professor of Law at The Australian National University and prior to that Professor of Jurisprudence at The University of Glasgow, UK. He has published extensively on Legal Theory and Political Philosophy.
Dr Kylie Bourne is Senior Research Assistant at the Regional Australia Institute. She was formerly Research Assistant at Charles Sturt University and prior to that, Research Management Coordinator in the College of Law at the Australian National University.
