Business History, 1991, p. 108. (Tony Adams):
"thought-provoking"
English Historical Review April 1991, p. 521 (G.W. Crompton):
"an ambitious study"
Scottish Labour History Society Journal 24 (1989), p. 104 (Jim Smyth):
"a valuable addition to the history of Scottish labour in the twentieth century".
History Today 38, Nov. 1988, p. 58 (Colin Holmes):
"a thorough and meticulous work which will need to be incorporated into the history of the Labour Party."