Preface |
|
v | |
Table of Cases |
|
xviii | |
Table of Legislation |
|
xxvi | |
Chapter 1 Overview |
|
1 | (16) |
|
|
1 | (1) |
|
Section B Questions Concerning The Nature Of Variations |
|
|
1 | (10) |
|
What variations are covered by this book? |
|
|
1 | (2) |
|
Why are variations made to the works? |
|
|
3 | (1) |
|
Why do construction contracts contain unilateral variation provisions? |
|
|
4 | (1) |
|
What are the characteristics of an instructed variation? |
|
|
5 | (1) |
|
What risks does a unilateral variation power pose for a contractor? |
|
|
6 | (1) |
|
Is a contractor entitled to extra money and time for additional work? |
|
|
7 | (1) |
|
What risks does a unilateral variations provision pose for an employer? |
|
|
8 | (1) |
|
What are the most common disputes that arise in relation to variations? |
|
|
9 | (2) |
|
Section C Summary Of Content By Chapter |
|
|
11 | (6) |
|
Chapter 2: Employer approval |
|
|
11 | (1) |
|
Chapter 3: Scope of works |
|
|
12 | (1) |
|
Chapter 4. Contractor's obligations in respect of the works |
|
|
12 | (1) |
|
|
13 | (1) |
|
Chapter 6. Variations required because of contractor risk |
|
|
13 | (1) |
|
|
13 | (1) |
|
Chapter 8. Variation instructions |
|
|
14 | (1) |
|
Chapter 9. Change in the absence of a variation instruction |
|
|
14 | (1) |
|
Chapter 10. Valuation process |
|
|
15 | (1) |
|
Chapter 11. Entitlement to money |
|
|
15 | (1) |
|
Chapter 12. Entitlement to time |
|
|
15 | (2) |
Chapter 2 Employer Approval |
|
17 | (16) |
|
|
17 | (3) |
|
Section B Employer Approval |
|
|
20 | (2) |
|
Section C Project Impasse |
|
|
22 | (7) |
|
Solutions to the problem of project impasse |
|
|
24 | (3) |
|
Refusal by employer to approve any change |
|
|
27 | (1) |
|
Disagreements as to the validity of the instruction |
|
|
27 | (1) |
|
Can the impossibility of undertaking work result in the frustration of a contract? |
|
|
28 | (1) |
|
Section D Complexity In Assessing Responsibility For Change |
|
|
29 | (3) |
|
Section E Approval Via Waiver And Concession |
|
|
32 | (1) |
Chapter 3 Scope |
|
33 | (72) |
|
|
33 | (4) |
|
Interpretation of contract documents |
|
|
34 | (1) |
|
Reasons for ambiguities and errors in the scope |
|
|
35 | (1) |
|
No requirement to instruct work already within the scope |
|
|
36 | (1) |
|
Section B Contract Interpretation |
|
|
37 | (13) |
|
Contradictions between documents |
|
|
39 | (3) |
|
|
42 | (1) |
|
Contractual obligation to undertake work not referred to |
|
|
43 | (1) |
|
Cases illustrating interpretation of the contract scope of works |
|
|
43 | (7) |
|
Section C Contractual Obligation To Undertake Work Not Expressly Referred To |
|
|
50 | (6) |
|
Extent of the contractor's discretion when departing from the scope |
|
|
53 | (1) |
|
Where the extra work does constitute a change under the variations clause |
|
|
54 | (1) |
|
Change ordered under a provision outside the contract mechanism |
|
|
55 | (1) |
|
|
56 | (1) |
|
Section D Impossibility Of Building The Described Scope |
|
|
56 | (7) |
|
Section E Build Risk And Methodology |
|
|
63 | (10) |
|
The description of the build methodology in contracts |
|
|
64 | (1) |
|
The contractor's buildability obligation |
|
|
65 | (3) |
|
No buildability risk taken by the contractor |
|
|
68 | (3) |
|
Changes required because the construction method proves inadequate |
|
|
71 | (1) |
|
Power of the employer to direct temporary works outside variation procedure |
|
|
72 | (1) |
|
|
73 | (10) |
|
The nature and extent of the contractor's design responsibility |
|
|
73 | (3) |
|
Changes required because of inadequate design |
|
|
76 | (1) |
|
Instruction procedure and the identification of an appropriate solution |
|
|
77 | (2) |
|
Design development and approval of design details |
|
|
79 | (3) |
|
Importance of correctly drafted employer's requirements |
|
|
82 | (1) |
|
Section G Deemed Variations |
|
|
83 | (2) |
|
Deemed variations triggered by an event |
|
|
83 | (1) |
|
Deemed variations to resolve discrepancies |
|
|
84 | (1) |
|
Section H Contract Procedures To Resolve Inconsistencies |
|
|
85 | (4) |
|
Section I Contracts With Alternative Pricing Models |
|
|
89 | (8) |
|
The remeasurement of quantities contrasted with variations |
|
|
91 | (2) |
|
Assessment of whether work is included in the rates |
|
|
93 | (2) |
|
Fixed scope with flexible categorisation of work types |
|
|
95 | (1) |
|
Sanctity of rates and changes in quantities |
|
|
96 | (1) |
|
|
97 | (1) |
|
Section J Contracts For Services |
|
|
97 | (8) |
|
|
99 | (2) |
|
|
101 | (4) |
Chapter 4 Contractor's Obligations In Respect Of The Works |
|
105 | (24) |
|
|
105 | (3) |
|
Obligation to construct the contract scope |
|
|
105 | (2) |
|
Contractor's obligation to build validly instructed variations |
|
|
107 | (1) |
|
The contractor's obligations in respect of additional work |
|
|
107 | (1) |
|
Section B Compliance With Scope |
|
|
108 | (3) |
|
Section C Entitlement To Be Paid For Nonconforming Work |
|
|
111 | (3) |
|
Section D Completion Certificates |
|
|
114 | (2) |
|
Section E Damages For Nonconforming Work |
|
|
116 | (5) |
|
Comparison of the different approaches to the assessment of damages |
|
|
117 | (4) |
|
Section F Standard Of Responsibility For Additional Works |
|
|
121 | (8) |
|
Design responsibility for varied work |
|
|
122 | (1) |
|
The contractor's right to refuse to undertake a variation |
|
|
123 | (1) |
|
Liability if the contractor proceeds with the variation |
|
|
124 | (3) |
|
Contractor's buildability obligations in relation to varied work |
|
|
127 | (2) |
Chapter 5 Power To Vary |
|
129 | (46) |
|
|
129 | (12) |
|
Characteristics of varied work |
|
|
133 | (1) |
|
Implied limits on the power to vary |
|
|
134 | (4) |
|
Contractor's refusal to undertake works and right to additional payment |
|
|
138 | (2) |
|
Employer's refusal to accept unauthorised work |
|
|
140 | (1) |
|
|
141 | (1) |
|
Section B Type And Method Of Work |
|
|
141 | (6) |
|
Method of undertaking work |
|
|
146 | (1) |
|
|
147 | (8) |
|
Express contract provisions to limit change |
|
|
148 | (2) |
|
Volume of variations changing the nature of the contract |
|
|
150 | (3) |
|
Adjustment of rates for variations and measurement contracts |
|
|
153 | (1) |
|
Limits on the amount of change because of uneconomic rates |
|
|
154 | (1) |
|
|
155 | (4) |
|
Uncertainty as to the cut-off date for variations |
|
|
156 | (2) |
|
|
158 | (1) |
|
Section E Omissions And Instructing Alternative Contractors |
|
|
159 | (12) |
|
The omission of work and redistribution to another contractor |
|
|
160 | (5) |
|
The omission of substantial amounts of work from a contract |
|
|
165 | (2) |
|
Changes to the project scheme and the instruction of new work |
|
|
167 | (2) |
|
|
169 | (2) |
|
Section F Third-Party Constraints |
|
|
171 | (4) |
|
|
171 | (1) |
|
|
172 | (1) |
|
Constraints under procurement legislation |
|
|
173 | (2) |
Chapter 6 Variations Required Because Of Contractor Risk |
|
175 | (12) |
|
|
175 | (2) |
|
Ways in which the employer can approve change |
|
|
176 | (1) |
|
The employer's duty to vary |
|
|
176 | (1) |
|
Disagreement as to the reasons for change |
|
|
176 | (1) |
|
Section B Contractor's Entitlement To Be Paid For Variation |
|
|
177 | (5) |
|
Valuation of the contractor's entitlement |
|
|
181 | (1) |
|
Section C Disputes As To Why Change Is Required |
|
|
182 | (5) |
|
Project impasse and interim agreement |
|
|
184 | (3) |
Chapter 7 Duty To Vary |
|
187 | (20) |
|
|
187 | (2) |
|
Circumstances in which the duty may need to be considered |
|
|
187 | (1) |
|
Different forms of employer approval |
|
|
188 | (1) |
|
The contractor's remedies if the employer refuses to authorise a change |
|
|
188 | (1) |
|
Duty to instruct the resident contractor rather than new contractor |
|
|
189 | (1) |
|
Section B Express And Implied Duties |
|
|
189 | (6) |
|
Express obligation to vary |
|
|
189 | (3) |
|
Obligation to exercise a discretion to vary |
|
|
192 | (1) |
|
Implied obligation to vary |
|
|
193 | (2) |
|
Section C Change As A Result Of Contractor Risk Or Request |
|
|
195 | (5) |
|
|
197 | (1) |
|
The employer's discretion to change |
|
|
198 | (1) |
|
Differences concerning the design solution |
|
|
199 | (1) |
|
Implications of the employer's refusal to approve change |
|
|
199 | (1) |
|
Section D Change As A Result Of Employer Risk |
|
|
200 | (7) |
Chapter 8 Variation Instructions |
|
207 | (26) |
|
|
207 | (3) |
|
Section B Written Instructions And Conditions Precedent |
|
|
210 | (11) |
|
The 'in writing' requirement |
|
|
215 | (1) |
|
Instructions that direct change and concessions |
|
|
215 | (4) |
|
Provisions requiring notice of claim |
|
|
219 | (2) |
|
Section C The Contract Administrator's Authority To Instruct Variations |
|
|
221 | (7) |
|
|
222 | (1) |
|
Agency law principles in the context of variation instructions |
|
|
223 | (1) |
|
Authority limited by the contract powers and procedures to vary |
|
|
224 | (2) |
|
Contract administrator has no ostensible authority to vary or waive compliance |
|
|
226 | (1) |
|
Limits on the contract administrator's actual authority |
|
|
227 | (1) |
|
Section D Prior Approval And Subsequent Sanction |
|
|
228 | (2) |
|
Section E Contract Mechanisms Providing For The Agreement Of Variations |
|
|
230 | (3) |
Chapter 9 Change In The Absence Of A Variation Instruction |
|
233 | (62) |
|
|
233 | (6) |
|
Reasons why a change is undertaken without a formal variation instruction |
|
|
234 | (3) |
|
Role of the contract administrator in authorising change |
|
|
237 | (1) |
|
Payment for additional work |
|
|
238 | (1) |
|
Limitations in relation to additional work ordered |
|
|
238 | (1) |
|
|
239 | (4) |
|
Concession or variation instruction |
|
|
240 | (1) |
|
Establishing whether a concession has been given |
|
|
241 | (1) |
|
Withdrawal of a concession |
|
|
242 | (1) |
|
The contract administrator's authority to permit a departure from the scope |
|
|
243 | (1) |
|
Section C Consensual Variation |
|
|
243 | (10) |
|
|
245 | (2) |
|
The contract administrator's authority to agree a consensual contract variation |
|
|
247 | (1) |
|
The form of the variation agreement |
|
|
248 | (3) |
|
|
251 | (2) |
|
Third-party restrictions on variations |
|
|
253 | (1) |
|
Section D Waiver Of Contractual Variation Mechanism Formalities |
|
|
253 | (10) |
|
Principles of waiver and estoppel |
|
|
254 | (3) |
|
Cases applying waiver and estoppel |
|
|
257 | (3) |
|
Implied promise to pay: Molloy v. Liebe |
|
|
260 | (1) |
|
Difficulties in establishing waiver and estoppel |
|
|
261 | (2) |
|
The contract administrator's authority to waive compliance |
|
|
263 | (1) |
|
Section E The Obligation To Approve And Instruct A Change |
|
|
263 | (7) |
|
Brodie: basis of the dispute |
|
|
265 | (2) |
|
Brodie: the arbitration provisions |
|
|
267 | (2) |
|
Obtaining payment for variations: court dispensing with the need for instruction |
|
|
269 | (1) |
|
Section F Collateral Contracts |
|
|
270 | (6) |
|
Additional work undertaken under a collateral contract |
|
|
273 | (2) |
|
The contract administrator's authority to agree a collateral contract |
|
|
275 | (1) |
|
Entitlements under a collateral contract |
|
|
276 | (1) |
|
Section G Restitution, Unjust Enrichment And Quantum Meruit Claims |
|
|
276 | (12) |
|
No restitution claim under a subsisting contract |
|
|
277 | (3) |
|
Relevance of restitution to variations |
|
|
280 | (1) |
|
The extra work cannot be undertaken under the subsisting contract |
|
|
280 | (1) |
|
Claims for restitution: no contract subsisting between the parties |
|
|
281 | (1) |
|
Contract not finalised by the parties |
|
|
281 | (2) |
|
|
283 | (1) |
|
|
284 | (1) |
|
Quantification of entitlement |
|
|
285 | (3) |
|
Section H Other Contractual Provisions That Compensate For Change |
|
|
288 | (7) |
|
Ground conditions clauses |
|
|
289 | (3) |
|
Loss and expense provisions |
|
|
292 | (3) |
Chapter 10 Valuation Process |
|
295 | (28) |
|
|
295 | (1) |
|
Section B Review Of Valuations And The Opening Up Of Certificates |
|
|
296 | (13) |
|
Contractual basis for the binding nature of certificates and the right of challenge |
|
|
296 | (1) |
|
Opening up and revising a contract administrator's certificate |
|
|
297 | (2) |
|
|
299 | (2) |
|
Contractor's applications for payment: timing and subsequent adjustment |
|
|
301 | (1) |
|
|
302 | (1) |
|
Certificates that are binding because the contract requires discretionary assessment |
|
|
303 | (2) |
|
Certificates that are determinative as to whether work is extra |
|
|
305 | (1) |
|
Opening up a 'final and binding' certificate because of deficiencies in form and procedure |
|
|
306 | (7) |
|
i The certificate purports to cover matters that it should not |
|
|
306 | (1) |
|
ii The certificate is not issued in the correct form and manner |
|
|
306 | (1) |
|
iii Parties' right to be heard |
|
|
307 | (1) |
|
iv Disqualification of the contract administrator for improper conduct |
|
|
307 | (2) |
|
Section C The Contract Administrator's Certification Role And Duties |
|
|
309 | (4) |
|
Section D The Employer's Duties In Relation To Certification |
|
|
313 | (5) |
|
The employer as certifier |
|
|
313 | (2) |
|
Duty not to interfere and to ensure the contract administrator performs |
|
|
315 | (2) |
|
Parties' agreement to have an independent certifier |
|
|
317 | (1) |
|
Section E Agreement Of Valuation And Settlement |
|
|
318 | (5) |
|
|
318 | |
|
|
310 | (10) |
|
|
320 | (3) |
Chapter 11 Entitlement To Money |
|
323 | (40) |
|
|
323 | (6) |
|
The two approaches to pricing changes |
|
|
324 | (3) |
|
|
327 | (1) |
|
The right to be paid for extra work |
|
|
327 | (1) |
|
Design and build contracts |
|
|
328 | (1) |
|
|
328 | (1) |
|
Overlap with other contract compensation provisions |
|
|
328 | (1) |
|
Section B Variations Valued By Reference To The Contract Sum |
|
|
329 | (17) |
|
Valuation using contract rates and the sanctity of prices |
|
|
330 | (4) |
|
Valuation using contract rates: methods of measurement |
|
|
334 | (1) |
|
Differences in work sufficient to justify a change to rates |
|
|
334 | (3) |
|
The use of contract rates for different work and extrapolating rates |
|
|
337 | (2) |
|
Stage 3 of the valuation rules: a 'fair' assessment |
|
|
339 | (4) |
|
The treatment of preliminaries, overhead and profit under 'fair' valuations |
|
|
343 | (2) |
|
General rate adjustment clauses |
|
|
345 | (1) |
|
Dayworks for non-measurable work |
|
|
345 | (1) |
|
Section C Variations Valued By Reference To A Price Schedule |
|
|
346 | (6) |
|
Standard form contracts using variation price schedules |
|
|
347 | (2) |
|
|
349 | (3) |
|
Section D Assessment If There Is No Valuation Provision |
|
|
352 | (4) |
|
Valuation using the contract mechanism is mandatory |
|
|
353 | (2) |
|
Price to be assessed under a contract where no agreement as to rates |
|
|
355 | (1) |
|
Section E Measurement Contracts |
|
|
356 | (4) |
|
Section F Relationship With Other Contractual Compensation Provisions |
|
|
360 | (3) |
Chapter 12 Entitlement To Time |
|
363 | (16) |
|
|
363 | (2) |
|
Extensions of time and damages for late completion |
|
|
363 | (1) |
|
Delaying effect of variations |
|
|
364 | (1) |
|
Section B Contracts With No Completion Date Or Extension Of Time Mechanism |
|
|
365 | (2) |
|
Section C Grounds For An Extension Of Time |
|
|
367 | (5) |
|
|
368 | (2) |
|
Other grounds for an extension of time |
|
|
370 | (2) |
|
Section D Delays Caused By Events Not Covered By The Extension Of Time Mechanism |
|
|
372 | (4) |
|
Liquidated damages entitlement when event not covered by extension of time mechanism |
|
|
372 | (2) |
|
Implied duty excluded by express provision |
|
|
374 | (2) |
|
Section E Application Of Delay Principles To Variations |
|
|
376 | (3) |
|
The parties agree changes to the scope without a formal instruction |
|
|
376 | (1) |
|
Unapproved changes to the works |
|
|
377 | (1) |
|
Impossibility of proceeding with the work as a result of employer risk |
|
|
377 | (1) |
|
Varied work undertaken outside the contract entirely |
|
|
378 | (1) |
Index |
|
379 | |